綠黨與社民黨合作之黨內新政治

本文以綠黨黨員論壇(Google Group)所能獲知的訊息為基礎,略述綠社合作過程中,我一個綠黨黨員的認知...

  • 合作的基調,是在年初的黨員大會中確立的。
  • 2015/03/09,共同召集人透過黨員論壇發表「致本黨黨員關於3/6和社民黨會面一事現況,感謝!!!」,向黨員徵詢意見。共有29 篇留言、18 位留言者。留言的都是黨員,並未有中執委參與對話。
  • 2015/06/26,有份雙方第一次合作會議的新聞稿
  • 04/23、06/30的中執委會議紀錄裡,約略有提到一些政黨合作的討論/決議。
  • 07/16、07/30還召開了臨時的中執委會議,不過沒有即時公布會議記錄(後來有公布,不過,本黨會議記錄一向都只有問題與結論,沒看到過程...)。
  • 來到08/06,發了一封「綠黨中執委會關於政黨合作近況的說明信」,說明「7 月 16 日,臨時中執委會通過繼續與社民黨協商合作案,過程中,中執委帶著地方議員、參選人、地方支黨部幹部等提出的協商條件,經過來回確認,終於在 7 月 31 日與社民黨代表達成協商共識。」以下摘錄部分內容:

    由於協商時程緊迫,且許多協商細節事涉選舉策略及政黨整合進度,無法即時向所有黨員公佈,因此使得黨內有資訊落差的情況發生。對此,中執委會要向關切政黨合作案的黨員同志們致上最深的歉意。
    另針對黨員關切的不分區排序問題,本周一晚間兩黨提名委員會曾召開溝通會議。初步決定待兩黨各自完成不分區提名及排序後,再送交參政聯盟共同提名委員會決定整體排序。
    本黨提名委員會亦於同日召開臨時會決議:
    1. 不分區準政治代理人先依 2016 立法委員選舉綠黨政治代理人提名辦法,開始進行第二階段提名作業,舉辦公開政見座談,經提名委員確認提名後,再討論綠黨本身的排序。綠黨舉辦之公開政見座談,提名委員會將派員出席。
    2.決定不分區排序前,提名委員會將另舉辦座談會邀集黨員及公民團體,針對不分區排序表示意見,供提名委員會參考。
    為彌補急迫協商過程中的資訊落差,期能在簽署備忘錄決策前充分理解黨員意見、進行對話,中執委會將與各地方支黨部合辦黨員座談會,跟各地黨員及黨友討論政黨合作事宜。座談會亦將尊重支黨部的安排,決定是否邀請未來的合作夥伴社民黨一同出席。待各地座談完畢後,中執委會將召開臨時會,確定是否正式簽署兩黨合作備忘錄。敬請黨員同志們能踴躍參加各支黨部座談,提供寶貴的意見。
    為了讓黨員充分了解參政聯盟推動過程與協商結果,茲提供:「政黨合作協商大事記」、「綠黨與社民黨合組參政聯盟之利弊及意見統整」、「社民黨簡介」、「綠黨社會民主黨參政聯盟合作備忘錄」等四份文件,請黨員參考。

  • 花生什麼事?原來,08/03有黨員說朋友傳給他一則新聞「黨內雜音不斷 第三勢力綠黨與社民黨合作尚待解決」...看到這個我和一些人都驚呆了,我只好留言說:

    「不知道所謂的黨內民主程序、或是程序問題,到底是什麼?就是看不見的提名委員會的內部表決嗎?如果只能從新聞、臉書訊息、電話、耳語來看到、聽到這些消息(據說五月底就已經有不分區名單了?),這絕對不是新政治啊~」

  • 於是在一週內,很快速地辦了四場支黨部座談會(08/21公布會議記錄),也邀請了社民黨的朋友來參加。然後也很有效率地,在08/15舉行臨時中執委會議,確認了「政黨合作與備忘錄簽署」。三天後,兩黨正式召開記者會宣布結盟合作。
  • 政黨合作座談會,頗有意思,也有一點點小火花,我個人在會後某串討論的留言是這樣:
    • 「答案在人心」的意思,我的理解就是原則上「沒有「不合作」這個選項」。或許,是因為年初黨員大會通過的「綠黨選舉整體策略討論案」,就是僅有合作的選項?(現在找不到該案全文...囧...)
    • 我比較不傾向合作,因為若選得好,就算有些實務上的摩擦與問題,但起碼會有資源可以持續成長。若是選不好/沒過3.5%,則後續發展會更困難。團結合作很好,但對我個人來說其實是賭一把。
    • 但是,我認同「以實質整合為前提進行合作」。雖然這似乎不大符合程序、黨員大會並未做出此授權。
    • 如前所述的賭一把,我想大家都有自己的政治判斷、利害分析,以及對於綠黨的付出與情感考量。若傾向不合作,並不代表不著眼於台灣,可能是更長期地看綠黨發展對於國家社會的利益。
    • 最後,還是要談一下我們被動的民主程序...如同小易的問卷,以及我出席週五晚間北北基座談會,座談會的確對於了解合作案有非常大的幫助。在座談會之前,對我來說,合作過程其實是宛如黑箱...(接下來換提名委員會多分享一些資訊了吧?)
    • 以及,信任是雙向的。今天投票選出的中執委,代表他們獲得較多數黨員的信任,也期待中執委能做新政治的好榜樣。相信在參選之時,沒有人會說如果壓力很大所以有可能會退出、或是因為個人工作很忙所以沒什麼時間參與黨務吧。希望以後藉由資訊的流動、以及意見的公開表達,能讓相互的信任變得更好。

講結論,就是,我個人認為我們的黨內民主有點被動。不是因為欠缺時間與資源,不是因為機制或技術不佳,而是少了一個鼓勵黨員參與黨內民主的預設心態。這樣其實不大能玩新政治吧?希望黨內諸委能在此事件後,能有更深刻的認知。

Comments

jerseys from china, nike huaraches, chrome hearts store, true religion outlet, philipp plein clothing, michael kors handbags, tory burch shoes, air max, air max 2015, brooklyn nets jersey, air max one, tommy hilfiger, atlanta hawks jersey, indoor soccer shoes, broncos nfl jersey, new balance canada, jordans, ralph lauren outlet online, bcbg max azria, burberry outlet store, adidas online, thomas sabo, longchamp, redskins nfl jersey, coach factory, bills nfl jersey, burberry handbags, oakley, jordan jerseys, oakley black friday, colts nfl jersey, barbour jackets, raptors jersey, kings jersey, knicks jersey, ralph lauren, salvatore ferragamo, mcm handbags, nike.com, jaguars nfl jersey, hollister, coach outlet online, michael kors bags, air max, rolex watches, jimmy choo shoes, vikings nfl jersey, nba jerseys, cheap nhl jerseys, true religion, polo ralph lauren, lunette oakley, coach store, burberry outlet, prada shoes, nike, air max 90, nike air max, phoenix suns, cheap jordans, kate spade outlet online, hermes birkin bag, nike air force, thomas sabo, under armour curry, celine bags, soccer shoes, omega watches, new balance, supra shoes, puma sneakers, ralph lauren, omega watches, nike mercurial, mont blanc, oakley sunglasses, coach factory online, red bottom shoes, giuseppe zanotti sneakers, ray ban wayfarer, nike, rams nfl jersey, nike tracksuits, the north face, air jordan retro, raiders nfl jersey, michael kors, adidas canada, fake rolex, north face, longchamp, armani shoes outlet, nike air yeezy, ray ban outlet online, prada, stone island outlet, beats audio, hermes, roshe runs, longchamp black friday, ralph lauren uk, basketball shoes, coach outlet online, cheap true religion, michael kors purses, cheap oakley sunglasses, michael kors outlet, hollister co, polo ralph lauren outlet online, marc jacobs, north face jackets, michael kors, nike free, oakley sunglasses cheap, mcm bags, mcm bags, michael kors outlet, max shoes, michael kors canada, burberry sale, michael kors, kids hoodies, bottega veneta, buccaneers nfl jersey, longchamp, air jordan shoes, hogan outlet, oakley vault, fred perry uk, jordans, rolex replica, coach store outlet, converse, cheap nhl jerseys, dsquared2 jeans, pandora schmuck, ray ban sonnenbrillen, dwyane wade jersey, jets nfl jersey, michael kors, charlotte hornets jerseys, christian louboutin shoes, chiefs nfl jersey, ray ban outlet, skechers mens shoes, vans, burberry handbags outlet, orlando magic jersey, instyler, ray ban, dolphins nfl jersey, ralph lauren factory store, nike air max 2014, five finger shoes, givenchy handbags, oakley, horloges, ed hardy, ray ban sunglasses outlet, skechers shoes outlet, dsquared2 outlet, ralph lauren online shop, vans, pandora jewelry, cheap nike shoes, san antonio spurs jersey, hugo boss clothes, coach outlet sale, pandora, burberry, ralph lauren, michael kors handbags, grizzlies jersey, juicy couture, roshe, coach factory outlet online, christian louboutin, jimmy choo outlet, michael kors, converse sneakers, ecco outlet online, omega, new balance outlet, hilfiger online shop, beats by dr dre, babyliss pro, polo ralph, burberry handbags, juicy couture outlet, jordan, texans nfl jersey, nba jersey, true religion jeans women, nike air max, oakley sunglasses outlet, ray-ban sunglasses, nfl jerseys, michael kors, denver nuggets jersey, oakley sunglasses, michael kors, fidget spinner, trail blazers jersey, burberry, michael kors, northface, giants nfl jersey, watches canada, converse shoes, packers nfl jersey, dansko outlet, cheap mlb jerseys, polo ralph lauren, cavaliers jerseys, designer handbags, eagles nfl jersey, titans nfl jersey, hogan women shoes, cheap oakley sunglasses, michael kors handbags, air jordans, softball bats, kate spade outlet online, birkenstock taschen outlet, tommy hilfiger, calvin klein underwear

Seeing the immortality is about to Coach Factory Outlet begin in the winter,UGG Boots Outlet autumn means that the real past,ugg boots said the winter is a dormant season,Coach Factory rest and recuperation time, then we do not have to be too tossing,UGGS For Women taking advantage of this peace,North Face Outlet it is better to Cheap UGG Boots tranquilize and improve themselves The connotation and quality of it.Coach Outlet Winter,North Face Outlet whether you consider choosing an elegant watch, even if the coat is tight,Nike Huarache in the moment Coach Outlet of raising his hand,Michael Kors it also appears refined,Coach Outlet saying that winter is a Coach Factory romantic season,Coach Factory Outlet although it is early winter,Adidas Yeezy Boost snow is not down yet Under, but does not prevent myself from becoming a warm and romantic person. According to the wave watch,Coach Outlet gold-plated craft to Michael Kors watch the overall warm color,Cheap Uggs coupled with brown leather strap,UGG Bailey Button refined tone can not hide.Michael Kors Outlet Interestingly,Markelle Fultz Shoes the dial on the scale,Michael Kors Outlet Store are selected diamond inlay,Cheap Moncler Jackets to be honest,Coach Black Friday many men can not True Religion Outlet control the diamond,Oakley Outlet but can wear a drill man, that wisdom and gentleman style, is obvious.Coach Outlet Online Diamonds are not exclusive to women. By wave itself is a very Coach Outlet romantic brand.
Dress table is standard in winter,Nike Outlet because Coach Purses the clothes to Coach Outlet wear more,Coach Outlet so we are Air Jordan 13 generally Michael Kors Outlet Store willing to choose some favored thin and elegant watch, on the one hand can be well Ralph Lauren Outlet matched with the clothes,Curry Jersey on the other hand wear it more fitting wrist. Cecil Clarke series is a very good choice for winter wear,North Face Outlet because the celebrity brand name is very gentleman taste,UGG Outlet Store elegant case shape,ugg boots and simple appearance,Cheap Jordans black and white classic colors, a diamond embellishment ,Yeezy Boost 350 V2 The details of The North Face Outlet the proper decent calm, and elegant personality, very comfortable,Coach Outlet but also lovable. Coach Outlet Online In Europe, Montblanc has a very high reputation, its long history of leather goods and writing instruments to Red Bottoms make such a brand full of elite.Uggs Outlets Montblanc traditional watch series, simple appearance,Cheap Air Max 90 polished stainless steel case,Swarovski Outlet flowing lines willow pointer,Moncler Jackets and fully automatic North Face Outlet winding mechanical movement,Ray Ban Sunglasses everything seems just right,North Face Outlet Store the Roman numeral scale gives Coach Outlet a classical texture, double bezel Generous and generous.North Face Outlet Winter is coming,Coach Outlet to replace those complex, sporty,Michael Kors Outlet cold equipment,North Face Jackets with some warm colors,REEBOK Classic comfortable clothing,True Religion Outlet skin-friendly decoration,NBA Jerseys to give this UGG Boots Black Friday winter some romance Buty Nike Air Max and elegance.Cheap Replica Handbags The style of the three Moncler Jackets watches have Kate Spade Outlet their advantages and disadvantages,Coach Outlet but without exception,North Face Outlet can make Christian Louboutin Shoes you prepared elegant,Coach Factory Outlet when the winter gentleman.
In the era of the Internet,Burberry Outlet the stylized North Face Outlet lifestyle has become the core Cheap Jordans spiritual appeal of consumers,Louis Vuitton Outlet especially young users. At the same time,Michael Kors Outlet there is an insurmountable Sac Longchamp gap between the North Face Outlet traditional handicraft industry and this Ugg Boots Sale efficiency-oriented era.Pandora Outlet However,Louis Vuitton any boutique that Louis Vuitton Outlet can become a piece Ray Ban Outlet of itself Behind them,North Face Jackets not just inspired and normalized production,Coach Outlet more polished day after day UGG Boots and tireless polish.Nike Air Max The "craftsmanship" Bijoux Pandora we call the craving is not UGG Outlet only a nostalgia for traditional craftsmanship, but also an indispensable temperament of an era.Relying on Sina's Moncler Outlet comprehensive portal and social media,North Face Outlet Sina Fashion has been committed to Nike Roshe Run creating a strong online lifestyle in the field of media.Burberry Belt With immediate effect, Chaussures Christian Louboutin Pas Cher Sina Fashion will officially launch the NHL Jerseys "2017 Style Awards" to bring together Kate Spade Outlet superior resources,UGG Boots advocate Chinese style,Adidas Outlet spread high-quality brands and product concepts,Kate Spade Outlet lead users to build a new lifestyle aesthetics,Nike Outlet face the cultural confrontation Moncler Outlet in the age of mixed age,Salomon Shoes Breaking the field of UGG Outlet professional consumer,Jordan 11 return to the user experience,Timberland Boots classic luxury brand to bring salute style.

Add new comment